| Name | Year Consecrated | Notes |
| Paul Athanasius | 1877 | Consecrated by Syrian Patriarch of Antioch, Ignatius Peter III and appointed Patriarchal Legate in Malabar |
| Francis Xavier Alvarez | 1889 | Paul Athanasius consecrated Alvarez assisted by Malabar Bishops Evanius and Gregorius |
| Joseph Rene Vilatte | 1891 | Alvarez consecrated Vilatte as Archbishop Metropolitan for America, assisted by Athanasius and Gregorius |
| Frederick E.J. Lloyd | 1915 | Consecrated by Vilatte assisted by Bishop Paul Miraglia. Lloyd succeeded Vilatte as Archbishop in 1920 |
| John Churchill Sibley | 1929 | Consecrated by Lloyd assisted by Archbishop Gregory and Bishops Daniel, Francis and Axel then appointed Archbishop Metropolitan for British Empire |
| John S.M. Ward | 1935 | Consecrated by Sibley and then succeeded him as Archbishop in 1938. Gained additional lines of Succession in 1945 |